This the second part of my review of The Hunger Games movie. If you haven’t yet read Part I, check it out here:
If you’ve not read all three Hunger Game books, and/or watched the movie, do not read this post. This is your one **Spoiler Alert**.
Continuing where I left off in Part I:
Then there’s the the stylist team and Cinna. All of the sudden, Katniss is hugging Cinna like he’s her best friend. We saw him on the screen for maybe a minute before then? We had no indication that he was different. We had no reason to think that he was on her side. The stylists didn’t even get named… How is it going to matter to us when Cinna is taken later? Then, there’s Rue. When Rue dies in the book, it’s like a punch to the heart. When Rue dies in the movie, it’s like when Dobby dies in Harry Potter. Said, but forgettable. In the books…you knew she probably had to die…but maybe she wouldn’t… No reason for me to even go into the Reaping scene when Katniss volunteers for Prim…I felt so little emotion while watching that, that it was immediately forgettable. So, as you can tell…there was very noticeable lack of emotional attachment. I felt 10% of the emotion that I felt in the book. And losing 90% of the emotion can’t be explained away by a lack of time… If this movie needed to be a two-parter, then so be it.
There are some things that I somewhat understand were changed due to time. To me, the MockingJay pin Katniss wears was one of the biggest. In the book, she gets it from the Mayor’s daughter, Madge, who comes to visit her during the “visitation period” right after the reaping. It’s a really big deal, and referred to quite often as the books go on. In the movie, she gets it, rather un-ceremoniously, from Greasy Sae. The Hob in general was really underplayed. In the movie, the only visitors Katniss gets are her mom/sister, and Gale. In the movie, we also see Madge and the baker. In the books, drinking water plays a major part in the Games. In the movie, they just didn’t really focus on it. The scenes where the forest is burning…the descriptions of her throat burning, and her lips cracking…nothing. This, again, was a time constraint issue, but man – those scenes were so hard-hitting. The Games themselves were really shortened for time. There is basically no character development at all of the other participants. The same can be said about President Snow – but I’m not so sure how much of that was actually even done in book 1. That may develop further into the series.
Katniss’ father, while excellently brought into play by the hallucination, was certainly missing. There was much off-screen talk made about the “hunting jacket” that Katniss wore. Costume designers talking about how they decided to just make it fit her perfectly, even though it was supposed to be her fathers. Well, shoot, if you didn’t read the book – you would not have known where it came from anyway, so who cares how it fit?!
I guess what I’m getting at…is that it just felt watered-down and rushed. I remember Kevin saying that he’s not sure how this movie won’t be rated “R”, and now I understand why… As a movie, by itself, it was good. If there was no book association, I’d give it a 3/5, and we’d move on. Because, as a movie, it really doesn’t deserve much more or less than that. It told a decent story – it had good acting – there was some emotion thrown in. After reading the books, however, I can’t help but be disappointed. Very disappointed. The books were so great, they were so well-written, that nothing but perfection would do. And, unfortunately, it’s hard to tell someone’s life perfectly in 2 and a half hours. It’s funny – I’ve talked to many people who have watched this movie. Those that never read the books, cried many times throughout the movie. Those that had read the books, not once. (And both sides had some habitual criers, I assure you…) It’s almost like we had all braced ourselves to see the horror play itself out on the screen. We all went in knowing that we will see some things that we can never un-see. And, instead, we saw a watered-down movie that could have just as well been played by adult actors, instead of teenagers. The roller-coaster just wasn’t in effect. In fact, there just wasn’t much of a climax at all in the movie. It just kind of…went until it ended. They always say that you should leave the audience wanting more…well…unless that means wanting more so that the movie would be better…Mission Accomplished.
I give The Hunger Games movie a 2/5. (Note: If this is ever released in a 4-hour director’s cut, a la Lord of the Rings, I may just have to write an addendum to this post.)


Like this:
Be the first to like this post.
Posted in Uncategorized
Tags: Emotion, Gale, Greasy Sae, Hob, Jennifer Lawrence, Madge, Movie, Peeta, Review, Rue, The Hunger Games